Skip to main content arrow-down arrow-tail-right arrow-triangle-right calendar camera compass download email eye facebook flag mail phone pin play send square-right tag twitter youtube badge message

UK Supreme Court finds Government’s decision to provide information to the United States to facilitate prosecution for crimes carrying the death penalty unlawful

  • News
  • 26 Mar 2020

In a unanimous decision delivered on 25 March 2020, the Supreme Court held that the UK Government had acted unlawfully in providing or agreeing to provide material to the United States, without seeking assurances that the death penalty would not be imposed.  The case was heard before an enlarged panel of seven Justices.

The appeal concerned two individuals, Shafee El Sheik and Alexanda Kotey, who were alleged to be part of a group of terrorists operating in Syria, involved in the murder of British and US citizens. This case was brought by the mother of Shafee El Sheik, Ms Maha Elgizouli, who applied for judicial review of the then-Home Secretary’s decision to knowingly facilitate the possible imposition of the death penalty in the United States.

The Death Penalty Project was admitted by the Court to intervene in these proceedings because of its long-standing expertise in the area of death penalty and international human rights law.

Parvais Jabbar, Co-Executive Director, says:

It has never been in dispute that Mr El Sheik and Mr Kotey should face trial for the serious crimes alleged against them, but any trial, if it is to take place, should be held in the UK. We intervened in this case because we believed the earlier actions of the UK Government were contrary to its long-standing approach on the death penalty, and could lead to a death sentence being imposed or carried out.

The importance of this decision is wider than just this case. It has implications for any individual who may be facing the death penalty and concerns what assurances the UK Government must seek before deciding what help or assistance it may give. These are fundamental issues concerning the right to life. The UK abolished the death penalty over 50 years ago and the Government must hold true to its commitment to oppose capital punishment in all circumstances and as a matter of principle.

Read the full judgment and press summary from the UK Supreme Court.

Related articles:

Supreme Court allows appeal on the UK’s facilitation of the death penalty abroad, News, Doughty Street Chambers, 25 March 2020

Notes to editors

Tim Owen QC of Matrix Chambers and Amanda Clift-Matthews (In-House Counsel) were instructed pro bono in the matter.

Latest news

Malaysian man has death sentence quashed as judgment in Singapore makes judicial history
Read More
British national received 24 strokes of the cane for drug offences in Singapore
Read More
New report finds Zimbabwean opinion leaders support abolition of the death penalty
Read More
Privy Council overturns murder conviction of unrepresented man who faced the death penalty in The Bahamas
Read More
Report on the views of opinion leaders on the reasons why the death penalty has not been abolished in the Eastern Caribbean and Barbados
Read More
Second Execution in Taiwan under President Tsai: Huge step backwards to Taiwan’s commitment to abolish the death penalty
Read More
UK Supreme Court finds Government’s decision to provide information to the United States to facilitate prosecution for crimes carrying the death penalty unlawful
Read More
Inter-American Commission urges retentionist member states within the OAS to eliminate the death penalty
Read More
Contradictions in Judicial Support for Capital Punishment in India and Bangladesh: Utilitarian Rationales
Read More
Indonesia: Build evidence-based policies on drugs and punishment
Read More
Capital sentencing and judicial attitudes towards the death penalty in India and Bangladesh
Read More
Press Release: The Death Penalty and Illegal Executions in Saudi Arabia
Read More
The Death Penalty and Executions in Saudi Arabia
Read More
Compounded Violence: Domestic Abuse and the Mandatory Death Penalty in Ghana and Sierra Leone
Read More
Delegation to Guyana on Sentencing in Capital Cases
Read More
Aron John, former death row prisoner, regains freedom after 16 years in prison in Malawi
Read More

Stay up-to-date with our work